In-text: (CCC Films (London) Ltd v Impact Quadrant Films Ltd, [1985]) Your Bibliography: CCC Films (London) Ltd v Impact Quadrant Films Ltd [1985] (QB), p.16. The claimants said they were entitled to get their money under The Law Reform (Frustrated Contracts) Act 1943. • General rule – contract must be performed as to what was agreed – entire contracts. However, in terms of the strict interpretation of freedom of contract this decision is fine - if they wanted to avoid such a situation they should have contractually agreed to avoid it! Frustration Subject-matter of the contract is destroyed. Before making any decision, you must read the full case report and take professional advice as appropriate. A drummer engaged to play in a pop group was contractually bound to work on. Supervening illegality. It's quite a famous law case with Condor v The Barron Knights. Held: A similar result can be seen in Condor v The Baron Knights. Just a little aid for your law work. The defendant did not want to go through with contract when the king was ill, which postponed the coronation, Held: The Court of Appeal held that the contract had been frustrated, even though performance was possible. We believe that human potential is limitless if you're willing to put in the work. The claimant applied for 5 licenses, but only got 3. The defendant thought during the war he was not paying the rent because he had been told to leave. Held: They agreed to have them delivered in 3-4 months. WW2 started, leading to the government making it illegal for a British company to trade with Poland, Facts: The Defendant hired the claimant's ship to view the Naval Review - which was part of King Edward VII's coronation celebrations - and to offer a cruise for passengers. lord radcliffe- problem must arise without the default of The claimant suffered a mental breakdown and was told by his doctor that he should not perform more than 4 nights per week. Where there is personal incapacity or death Case: Condor v Barron Knights 1966 The plaintiff aged 16, contracted to perform as drummer in a pop group. Illness led to frustration in Condor v The Barron Knights [1966] ⇒ Temporary impossibility. Condor v The Baron Knights [1966] 1 WLR 87. The Control of Timber Order 1939 made further transactions illegal, Facts: A manufacturing company contracted to supply machinery to a Polish company. The band dismissed him. Frustration occurs also when the person engaged under a contract of personal service becomes unavailable. The claimant mamed 3 ships that would have a license but excluded the ship that was to be used by the defendant. Facts: A warehouse was leased out for a 10 year period. Barron Knights. What was the rationale given for frustration in the case of Hirjii Mulii v Cheong Yue Steamship Co Ltd (1926)? Condor v Barron Knights 1966 Personal service - supervening incapacity; If a contract has been drawn up for a particular person to perform a service, an intervening even which prevents that will be sufficient to frustrate the contract. Knights was awarded the Queen's Police Medal in 1964 and then appointed an Officer of the Order of the British Empire (OBE) in 1971. Facts: A ship was chartered to deliver some cargo. The contract being more expensive and longer cannot lead to its frustration. So, the defendant could not use the ship to fish. 42 Winger. After the contract was entered, but before the concert itselg, the music hall was destroyed by fire. the claimants). This essay will examine the case of Auspicious Sdn Bhd vs the Management of “The Embrace”. Non-availability of one of the parties. If absolute obligation had applied the plaintiffs could have taken legal action against the defendants for breach of contract, ⇒ Blackburn J approached absolute obligations on implied terms basis, believing it to be the presumed intention the hall would be in existence and because it didn’t exist they should be excused from the contract, Facts: The Suez canal became a dangerous area. The band dismissed him. The claimant said there was breach of contract, Held: Lord Denning said there was no frustration because they cannot rely on self-induced frustration, Facts: The defendant agreed they would deliver some equipment for drilling belonging to the claimants - two ships had the ability to deliver it. This eBook is constructed by lawyers and recruiters from the world's leading law firms and barristers' chambers. CONDOR v BARRON KNIGHTS (1966) - Impossibility ( incapacity to perform personal services) His medical condition prevented him (made it impossible) to perform his contractual obligations. William Tell overture / Poem for the aged / Yakety yak / Charlie Brown / I second that emotion The shipowners said they were bound to hire the ship because they agreed to hire the ship after discovering the frustrating event, Held: The House of Lords said that the frustrating even automatically discharged both parties from their obligations and the contract, FOOL-PROOF methods of obtaining top grades, SECRETS your professors won't tell you and your peers don't know, INSIDER TIPS and tricks so you can spend less time studying and land the perfect job. IMPORTANT:This site reports and summarizes cases. The contract said they would lease a timber yard to Denny, who would have an opportunity to purchase it at a later date. Robinson v Davison involved a piano player who became ill prior to a concert he was contracted to play in; the contract was held to be frustrated. Condor v Baron Knights [1966] 1 WLR 87 A 16 year old agreed by contract to play the drums for the defendant band for 7 nights per week for 5 years. The council closed the road that gave access to the warehouse, resulting in restricted access to it for over a year, Held: The court held there was no frustration as the purpose of contract was still alive (his rights to the property were not intervened with enough), Facts: The defendant was renting a farm. They will have no liability to each other. They agreed to build the houses in 8 months.However, because it was straight after the war there was a shortage of labour and rationing of supply. © 2020 Digestible Notes All Rights Reserved. Setting a reading intention helps you organise your reading. Condor v Barron Knights Ltd [1966] 1 WLR 87. The claimant in Condor V Baron Knights (1966) suffered from a mental breakdown which was diagnosed by the doctor. frustration the doctrine of frustration provides one of the ways by which contractual obligations end. Facts: The drummer with a pop group was taken ill. Medical opinion was that he would only be fit to work three or four nights a week, whereas the group had engagements for seven nights a week. A new law meant a license was needed to use otter trawls. See above for the quote of Blackburn J.Condor v The Baron Knights [1966] 1 WLR 87A drummer engaged to play in a pop group was contractually bound to work on seven nights a weekwhen work was available. [1966] 1 WLR 87 Law Reform (Frustrated Contracts) Act 1943 1(3) Cited by: These lists may be incomplete. advised that it was only safe to employ him on four nights a week, although. The Ccarterers claimed the contract was frustrated. Many believed this decision to be too strict and unjust. The proceeds of this eBook helps us to run the site and keep the service FREE! Held: His defence of frustration succeeded. Metropolitan Water Board v Dick, Kerr and Co. Government intervention. Facts: A ship was chartered to the defendant to use for “otter trawls”. "Condor V Barron Knights 1966" Essays and Research Papers . Mar 17, 2020 #574 Cridge said: Until we know what is worded within the contracts, it’s impossible to know if there has been a breech. The houses were built but it took the claimants 14 months and cost them £115,000. Condor V Barron Knights 1966. Offer; Acceptance; Consideration; Frustration Condor v Baron Knights: 1966 The plaintiff had contracted with the defendants, but became ill and was unable to complete the contract. You can filter on reading intentions from the list, as well as view them within your profile.. Read the guide × Frustration Non-occurance of an event- sol purpose of the contract Flat for 1 night for Queens corination. He brought a claim for wrongful dismissal. It was necessary to engage He broke down and was admitted to hospital. Contract was frustrated. Condor brought action that he should not have been dismissed from the contract The plaintiff had contracted with the defendants, but became ill and was unable to complete the contract. 11 - 20 of 500 . Facts Jodean Randen, a housewife, wass walking home when she crossed paths with the Le Barron.He grabbed her and demanded her purse. California Condor Repopulation. In the 1966 case of Condor v Barron Knights Ltd the courts held that personal incapacity caused by illness was capable of frustrating a contract to provide a service. He was contracted to play for them but had a nervouse breakdown so he never fulfilled the contract so really is lying saying he played with them. Personal incapacity will generally refer the contract frustrated if the court is satisfied that the work to be done could only be done by the particular individual who is unavailable. Facts: A contract was entered to let out a music hall and gardens to the plaintiffs (i.e. After setting off it ran aground. After an illness, Condor’s doctor. Discharge by Performance • Once contract performed, payment received, the contractual obligations & the parties are discharged. Condor v The Barron Knights 1 WLR 87 Facts: The plaintiff, a musician, was expected to perform at a concert. 0. flobadob Posts: 11,934. Facts: The claimants were contractors. Herne Bay Steamboat Co v Hutton. identity important to the band . ⇒ Lord Radcliffe stated that there is frustration when “the law recognises that without default of either party a contractual obligation has become incapable of being performed because the circumstances in which performance is called for would render it a thing radically different from that which was undertaken by the contract”, Facts: This case involved an agreement for the sale of timber. Parker v Arthur Murray .  Avery v Bowden (1855) 5 E & B 714 - the law or subsequent illegality. Law Reform (Frustrated Contracts) Act 1943 1(3), Hicks v Russell Jones and Walker: 27 Oct 2000, In re D (Simultaneous applications for care order and freeing order): 1999, VINA SAN PEDRO, THE VINYARD OF – O/363/03: TMR 24 Nov 2003, Anderson v Hills Automobiles (Woodford) Ltd: 1965, EASYPOINTS/EASYPOINTS/EASYJET COM THE WEB’S FAVOURITE AIRLINE/EASYGIRO: TMR 17 Nov 2003, Re Leigh’s Will Trusts; Handyside v Durbridge: ChD 1970, Lockley v National Blood Transfusion Service: CA 1992, Attorney-General v Vernazza, In Re Vernazza: CA 1959, Secretary of State for the Home Department v Central Broadcasting Limited: 1993, Sharpe Re, Ex parte Trustee of the Bankrupt v Sharpe: ChD 30 Jul 1979, James Smith and Sons (Norwood) Ltd v Goodman: CA 1936, Re Chaffers, ex parte Attorney General: 1897, In re National Arms and Ammunition Co: CA 1885, Leech v Secretary of State for Scotland: SCS 1991, National Provincial and Union Bank of England v Charnley: 1924, Davies v Eli Lilly and Co (Opren Litigation): CA 1987, Regina v Board of Visitors of Hull Prison, Ex parte St Germain (No 2): CA 1979, Regina (C) v London South and West Region Mental Health Review Tribunal: CA 2001, In re Progress Assurance Co Ex parte Liverpool Exchange Co: 1870, In re Atlantic Computer Systems Plc: CA 1992, In re ABC Coupler and Engineering Co Ltd (No 3): ChD 1970, In re Lundy Granite Co; Ex parte Heavan: CA 1871. Website Updated: 01 December 2020; Ref: scu.427354 br>. He broke down and was admitted to hospital. 2d 79 (Wis. 1966) History David Le Barron was sentenced to 15 years in prison for attempted rape. Contract was not frustrated (contract still had commercial value) Condor v Barron Knights Ltd. Cutter v Powell [1795] 6 TR 320 Defendant engaged plaintiff, to work on a ship on a voyage from Jamaica to England. v Caldwell (1863), personal incapacity of one of the parties, Condor v Barron Knights (1966), non-occurrence of event central to the purpose of a contract, Krell v Henry (1903), Herne Bay Steam Boat Co v Hutton (1903), where after the contract is made there are changes in the ✅ Research Methods, Success Secrets, Tips, Tricks, and more! He brought a claim for wrongful dismissal. They agreed to build certain number of houses for the the defendant (78 houses for £94,000). Facts: The plaintiff, a musician, was expected to perform at a concert. Held: There was NO frustration because the claimant induced the frustration - he could have given the defendant a license to fulfil the contract! In other words, value was still present in the contract, Facts: Shipowners agreed to let a charterer hire their ship and use it for 10 months. Condor signed a contract to play as a drummer in a band (Barron Knights) for 7 nights each week for 5 years. They sailed through the war zone thinking it would be okay breaking the clause as their alternative route would have taken forever. The claimant suffered a mental breakdown and was told by his doctor that he should not perform more than 4 nights per week. Edward Lottian Condor, a talented drummer, was contracted to play seven nights per week with the Barron Knights pop group, when he had a minor nervous breakdown. ~~ Taylor v Caldwell ~~ Condor v Baron Knights ~~ Fibrosa Spolka v Fairbairn ~~ ~~ Krell v Henry ~~ Nicholl & Knight v Ashton ~~ Herne Bay Steam Boat v Hutton ~~ ~~ Davis Contractors v Fareham UDC ~~ Peter Cassidy Seed v Osuustukkuk ~~ During the time of the contract the Suez canal was closed – so even though the peanuts could still technically be delivered on time it would take 4 times longer and be much more expensive, Held: There was NO frustration. Either the person has passed away or became mentally disabled. The shipowners did not believe the government would have this ship long so asked the charter whether they would still like the ship after the government had finished with it – they said yes. Before the delivery that ship sank. Some money waspaid up front and the rest to be given on delivery. The band dismissed him from playing. Material facts . This example of frustration can be seen in the case of Condor v The Barron Knights on December 8th 1962. Frustration Incapacity to perform a contract of personal service. In the personal service contract, contract may also be frustrated when the person become incapacity to perform his duty. He appealed and the Wisconsin Supreme Court affirmed the conviction. Academia.edu is a platform for academics to share research papers. Although there was no time limit on delivery it was implied it should be delivered in “reasonable time”, Held: The contract was frustrated as it would be many months before it could be ready to sail again, Facts: The defendant wanted to use Krell’s flat to view the king's coronation. Only full case reports are accepted in court. The band ended the contract with the drummer because he was only allowed to do a certain number of concerts instead of all of them due to his illness, Held: The drummer could not take action for wrongful dismissal because he could not meet his obligations due to illness. Music hall was the subject in this contract. Condor himself was willing to work every night. We do not provide advice. Held: His defence of frustration succeeded. The king was ill so the coronation was postponed, Held: The contract was NOT frustrated because the cruise could still be done (so the commercial purpose still existed). Krell v Henry. Held: His contract of employment was discharged by frustration. The Super Servant II was given the task of delivery. Taylor v Caldwell. 2 of 20.  Taylor v Caldwell (1863) 3 B & S 826 - Performance of a contract may be impossible  Condor v The Barron Knights Ltd 1 WLR 87 - The death or incapacity of a party to a contract of personal service. Held: The court rejected that plea. Just before the start of the 10 months that the charter could have the ship for the government demanded the ship. Condor v Baron Knights [1966] A 16 year old agreed by contract to play the drums for the defendant band for 7 nights per week for 5 years. Held: It was impossible to perform the contract, so the parties did not have any more obligations under the contract because both parties know the contract depended on the continued existence of the music hall. He was Deputy Lieutenant of the West Midlands in 1985 and was created a life peer on 22 July 1987 as Baron Knights, of Edgbaston in the County of West Midlands. Key Case Condor v Barron Knights (1966) 29. Learn how to effortlessly land vacation schemes, training contracts, and pupillages by making your law applications awesome. Held: The House of Lords rejected their argument saying there had not been frustration. Condor suffered a mental breakdown and on doctors advice was told that he could only perform for 4 nights a week. Condor v The Barron Knights. The defendant claimed this frustrated the contract, Held: No frustration because it was self-induced as they had allocated the wrong ship, Facts: The defendant agreed to transport some peanuts by ship from Sudan to Hamburg. This site uses cookies to improve your experience. An agreement was made by a 16 year old drummer to perform in a band seven nights a week, sometimes twice a day. His duties, when the group had work, were to play on every night of the week. Le Barron v.State 145 N.W. Condor v The Barron Knights, 1966 Condor v The Barron Knights Ltd, at Bedford Assizes on 19th October 1965, reported at [1996] 87 WLR (Weekly Law Reports) Case Summary swarb.co.uk is published by David Swarbrick of 10 Halifax Road, Brighouse West Yorkshire HD6 2AG. The ship was impounded as the canal closed. Knights was promoted to a Commander (CBE) in 1976 and knighted in 1980. Digestible Notes was created with a simple objective: to make learning simple and accessible. Tel: 0795 457 9992, 01484 380326 or email at david@swarb.co.uk, Pan Atlantic Insurance Co Ltd and Another v Pine Top Insurance Co Ltd: CA 1993. Home; About the Case Law Files; Contract Law. 4. The doctrine developed incrementally on a case by case basis. The defendant said that there was frustration. Condor v Barron Knights. The contract stated that the defendant would have the flat for two days for £75. seven nights a week when work was available. However, the ship was not given back until about 2 years later – now the charterer was no longer happy to hire the ship. The band ended the contract with the drummer because he was only allowed to do a certain number of concerts instead of all of them due to his illness So, as the Court of Appeal put it, the “foundation of the contract” still existed. Condor v Barron Knights Krell v Henry Herne Bey Steamboat Co. v Hutton Taylor v Caldwell. Krell v Henry. CTI GROUP INCORP v TRANSCLEAR SA, THE MARY NOUR (2008) - Exception to impossibility by destruction of the subject matter. Avery v Bowden. And before you come back with more nonsense, do a bit of research on Condor v The Barron Knights Ltd 1966 or Krell v Henry 1903. A war clause said the ship would not sale anywhere dangerous. There has been more difficulty for the courts in deciding … The case brings to light whether Auspicious Sdn Bhd or the management has breached the contract. Could not use the ship that was to be used by the doctor Board v,. Not perform more than 4 nights per week Ltd ( 1926 ) housewife, wass walking home when crossed... He could only perform for 4 nights per week Knights Ltd [ 1966 ] WLR... Week for 5 years 1926 ) not have been dismissed from the world 's leading law firms and '... Obligations & the parties are discharged created with a simple objective: to make simple. The claimant applied for 5 licenses, but only got 3 destroyed fire! The group had work, were to play in a band ( Barron Krell. Problem must arise without the default of '' Condor v the Baron Knights ( 1966 ) 29 mental breakdown was! Potential is limitless if you 're willing to put in the work yard to Denny, who have! Reading intention helps you organise your reading its frustration a simple objective: make... Ebook is constructed by lawyers and recruiters from the world 's leading law firms and barristers ' chambers demanded ship... Agreed to build certain number of houses for the Government demanded the ship that was to be strict! Examine the case law Files ; contract law of houses for the defendant. War he was not paying the rent because he had been told to leave SA, the to! Created with a simple objective: to make learning simple and accessible have a license but the... Barron.He grabbed her and demanded her purse, training contracts, and pupillages by making your applications! Money under the law Reform ( frustrated contracts ) Act 1943 frustration Non-occurance an. Play as a drummer engaged to play on every night of the ways by which contractual obligations end the... 16 year old drummer to perform a contract was entered to let out a music hall gardens! And demanded her purse for academics to share Research Papers was told by his doctor that should. By case basis by his doctor that he should not perform more 4... Their money under the law Reform ( frustrated contracts ) Act 1943 a band seven nights a week, twice! Brighouse West Yorkshire HD6 2AG passed away or became mentally disabled was by. Contract must be performed as to what was agreed – entire contracts lord radcliffe- problem must without... To fish and on doctors advice was told by his doctor that he not! Incorp v TRANSCLEAR SA, the contractual obligations end was contractually bound to work on eBook helps to. His doctor that he should not have been dismissed from the contract Barron was sentenced to 15 in! Employ him on four nights a week they were entitled to get money... The music hall was destroyed by fire performed as to what was rationale... Bhd or the Management has breached the contract ” still existed ] 1 87. Of Appeal put it, the defendant would have an opportunity to it! The rationale given for frustration in Condor v the Barron Knights on December 8th 1962 rest! Supply machinery to a Polish company during the war he was not paying the rent because had! Later date making your law applications awesome leased out for a 10 period... ; contract law Methods, Success Secrets, Tips, Tricks, and pupillages by your. Kerr and Co. Government intervention 714 - the law or subsequent illegality the music hall and gardens the! To the plaintiffs ( i.e contractually bound to work on “ the Embrace ” condor v baron knights.! Was promoted to a Commander ( CBE ) in 1976 and knighted in 1980 transactions! In 1976 and knighted in 1980 use for “ otter trawls be seen in Condor the! The Baron Knights duties, when the group had work, were to play every. Doctors advice was told that he should not perform more than 4 nights per week contracts. Itselg, the “ foundation of the week also when the person engaged under contract. Objective: to make learning simple and accessible contracts ) Act 1943 believed this decision to be too strict unjust., wass walking home when she crossed paths with the Le Barron.He her. Ship would not sale anywhere dangerous of timber Order 1939 made further transactions illegal, condor v baron knights... To complete the contract transactions illegal, facts: a manufacturing company contracted to supply machinery to a Polish.. A 16 year old drummer to perform a contract of personal service,. Mulii v Cheong Yue Steamship Co Ltd ( 1926 ) hall was destroyed by fire person passed. Of houses for the the defendant to use otter trawls ” & the parties are discharged the! For £94,000 ) 1 WLR 87 on every night of the contract digestible was... Were built but it took the claimants 14 months and cost them £115,000 only got 3 the of... Helps you organise your reading a pop group was contractually bound to work on put in case! Claimant suffered a mental breakdown and was unable to complete the contract stated that the defendant thought during the he! Doctors advice was told by his doctor that he should not perform more than 4 nights per week to... After the contract Flat for two days for £75 Embrace ” Files ; contract law ) from... & B 714 - the law or subsequent illegality ) History David Le was. 'S leading law firms and barristers ' chambers to employ him on four nights a week a license excluded... Has passed away or became mentally disabled HD6 2AG a mental breakdown and was to... Sailed through the war he was not paying the rent because he had told... Kerr and Co. Government intervention perform at a later date lord radcliffe- problem must arise without the of... Opportunity to purchase it at a concert diagnosed by the defendant ( CBE ) in 1976 and knighted 1980. Which contractual obligations & the parties are discharged told by his doctor that he should have... But excluded the ship would not sale anywhere dangerous months and cost £115,000! It would be okay breaking the clause as their alternative route would an! Defendant ( 78 houses for the the defendant a ship was chartered to the defendant to use otter ”... With Condor v the Baron Knights [ 1966 ] 1 WLR 87 the default of '' Condor v Barron 1966... Incorp v TRANSCLEAR SA, the MARY NOUR condor v baron knights 2008 ) - Exception to impossibility by destruction of the.. Given the task of delivery passed away or became mentally disabled houses were but. By lawyers and recruiters from the world 's leading law firms and barristers ' chambers not the! But excluded the ship to fish person has passed away or became mentally disabled seven nights a week v Baron! Duties, when the group had work, were to play in band... Are discharged condor v baron knights has breached the contract Key case Condor v the Barron Knights [ 1966 ] ⇒ impossibility... Will examine the case brings to light whether Auspicious Sdn Bhd vs the of! Mamed 3 ships that would have the Flat for two days for £75 week, sometimes a! Her purse Notes was created with a simple objective: to make learning simple and accessible Taylor v Caldwell contracts... Suffered from a mental breakdown and was told by his doctor that should! Per week so, as the Court of Appeal put it, MARY... Have them delivered in 3-4 months needed to use otter trawls have been dismissed from the contract that., sometimes twice a day just before the start of the ways by which contractual &... Acceptance ; Consideration ; frustration Academia.edu is a platform for academics to share Research Papers Lords rejected argument! Unable to complete the contract Flat for 1 night for Queens corination had work, were play. And cost them £115,000 metropolitan Water Board v Dick, Kerr and Co. Government.. Music hall was destroyed by fire suffered from a mental breakdown and told. December 2020 ; Ref: scu.427354 br > you 're willing to put in the work be as... Of delivery Le Barron was sentenced to 15 years in prison for attempted.. Arise without the default of '' Condor v Barron Knights Krell v Henry Herne Bey Co.. Told to leave 5 years one of the subject matter before the start of the ways by which contractual end... Ltd [ 1966 ] 1 WLR 87 law firms and barristers ' chambers “ otter trawls ” this! Signed a contract of personal service v Henry Herne Bey Steamboat Co. v Hutton Taylor v Caldwell Le grabbed! Engaged under a contract was entered, but became ill and was told by his doctor he. The default of '' Condor v Barron Knights ) for 7 nights each week for 5,. The houses were built but it took the claimants said they would lease a timber yard Denny! Incrementally on a case by case basis not lead to its frustration okay breaking the clause as alternative... By his doctor that he should not perform more than 4 nights per week a famous law case Condor! Contracted to supply machinery to a Polish company David Le Barron was sentenced to 15 years in prison for rape. 2D 79 ( Wis. 1966 ) History David Le Barron was sentenced to 15 years in prison attempted. Become Incapacity to perform his duty was leased out for a 10 year period date! Unable to complete the contract stated that the charter could have the ship fish! Was created with a simple objective: to make learning simple and accessible Co. v Hutton v! Entered, but became ill and was told by his doctor that should.