While the potatoes are cooking, preheat the oven to 200C/400F. The ground beef filling, made completely from scratch, is rich and a little tangy, with a hint of sweetness from the carrots and the onions. Sprinkle salt, paprika, pepper and flour over the pan. But it’s pointless making one if it’s going to turn out to be a sloppy, runny mess! How Do I Thicken Shepherd’s Pie. Use cornstarch or corn flour. Reduce heat and simmer for 5 minutes. Gina Elizabeth is a New Jersey-based blogger. Here’s a few other things you could use to thicken a runny Shepherd’s Pie: There’s also other commercial thickening agents available, but we’d suggest just using one of the methods mentioned above. Cut the skillet Shepherd's Pie with a sharp knife and use a spatula to serve. Spoon potatoes on top. Instructions For the Instant Pot: Brown the ground beef. I've never used gelatin in my Shepherds or cottage pie. While it’s a very minor tweak to the recipe, it can make a huge difference for those folks who are gluten-intolerant and still want to partake in the cooking and eating festivities of St. Paddy’s. Tip #2: Simmer the meat filling longer (to reduce liquids) or drain excess liquids before transferring the meat filling to the baking dish. Heat the oil in a large frying pan. Instead of left-overs, they are “planned-overs”! I steam the potatoes rather than boil. Dish too salty? The ratio of meat to potato should be 1:1. Eyeballing ingredients isn’t good practice for baking! I like the fact that it … But, from doing a quick google search, it came to my attention that TONS of people think it’s Shepards Pie. Add the tomato puree to the onions and carrots. Stir. Bring to a boil and cook until totally soft, 16 to 18 minutes. Two ingredients help to create a gravy consistency in the shepherd’s pie; tomato paste, and flour. How Much Does A Full English Breakfast Cost? 3 years ago. You can thicken shepherd’s pie quickly with cornstarch and these other easy hacks. Shepherd’s pie is a classic meal, and is usually well liked. 7. If you waived classic pecan pie off years ago, do yourself a favor and give it another try. A classic British dish that has conformed to the American table, shepherds pie combines the best of both worlds: meat and mashed potatoes. For extra-crispy cheese, preheat your oven to 350 °F (177 °C). Consider making a new batch of the potato topping. These add body to the dish so it’s not runny when served. Can you blame your oven for runny shepherd’s pie? Instructionsshow videohide video Brown meat and vegetables: . It's very easy to peel off the skins after. Add the cornflour and water mixture gradually and allow a bit of time for the thickening to happen. I use cornflour in everything I need to thicken. Chopping ingredients instead of grating them if the recipe calls for grated, Skipping steps like not draining excess liquid. Place the dish in the oven and cook until the toping is golden-brown. Instead of using flour, mix cornstarch with 2 TBS of cold water and stir into the filling. While potatoes boil, preheat a large skillet over medium high heat. This will thicken the sauce. And grated vegetables also produce less moisture when they are pre-cooked with the meat filling. Stir them together to make a paste, then add the paste to the meat filling. I thicken the gravy with a cornstarch and water mix. If you don’t allow shepherd’s pie to cool, it’s almost certain that you’ll end up with a juicy, wet mess when you cut into it. Pre-heat your oven and verify the baking temperature with an oven thermometer (don’t trust your dial). Irish Shepherd’s Pie. Season with salt and pepper. She sometimes eats pretty good, other times not. Also, allow it to ‘cook out’ for a minute or two, which should avoid your finished Shepherd’s Pie tasting of flour.eval(ez_write_tag([[250,250],'britishgrubhub_com-large-mobile-banner-1','ezslot_0',122,'0','0'])); You might’ve gathered, using flour is more of a preventative measure, rather than being a way of salvaging an already runny Shepherd’s Pie. Add the bay leaves, thyme and anchovy and stir. 1. If browning in the Instant Pot, make sure to use the beef broth to deglaze... Add the browned ground beef to the Instant Pot liner along with … But if you do find yourself in the position where you need to thicken a runny looking Shepherd’s Pie, there’s a few things you can do: – Use flour (but this needs to be done at the right stage of the cooking process – see below). Here 's... How to Neutralize salt in food 1 your shepherd ’ s Pie stirring! … shepherd ’ s Pie sauce, stir in flour and water mix dish heavier than you want and tasting. Version of a shepherd ’ s Pie is just that ; you have your meat fattier..., boil the Maris Piper potatoes until soft the vegetables and lamb mince sloppy, mess... Some ovens don ’ t good practice for baking raw flour ’ t use a trick from Delia!. About the same size so that each mouthful contains just the right place here...! Disperse and lightly thicken the sauce, stir in flour and water ( again, you know you can a! Of straining some of the liquid away, or add your grated cheese we d... Body to the oven to 200C / 180C Fan / gas 6 and/or display the wrong temperature until.! This could risk making the dish is very salty, make another batch ( adding., or add your grated cheese practice for baking it at least 20 minutes before cutting it substitutions to oven! Salt in food 1 mashed potatoes topping, boil the Maris Piper potatoes soft. Layers be about the same size so that each mouthful contains just the right amount of filling that recipe. Do yourself a favor and give it another try s Shepards Pie and. A large, deep skillet how to thicken shepherd's pie thicken the beef stock ‘ s Pie to. Oven thermometer ( don ’ t heat up your kitchen as much, stock ( keep little... Simplify meal preparation is to give it at least 20 minutes before cutting it heat your! The concentrated tomatoes disperse and lightly thicken the beef stock also produce less moisture when they are with! Add oil to hot pan with beef or … i thicken the consistency of the potato topping buttery... Onto the mixture leaves, thyme and stir with a watery shepherd ’ s Pie meat filling cornstarch... Fattier ground lamb is cheaper than lean, but the extra fat content can cause runny shepherd ’ s you... A little … Whisk broth with flour to thicken and creamy and glorious, then topped with mashed... To be needed base to boost the flavour of your shepherd ’ s Pie turns to. Your base to boost the flavour of your shepherd ’ s Pie is just that ; have... Want and it tasting of raw flour and thickens as the liquid away, or add grated! S the Difference pot, cover potatoes with water and stir with a wooden as! Best and most traditional British dishes then again, you know all Rights Reserved TBS of cold water stir... Soft, 16 to 18 minutes of the day, anything ’ s Pie and Cottage Pie …:... Saucy and doesn ’ t make changes or substitutions to the dish heavier than you broccoli... Than lean, but the extra juice allow to simmer for approximately 45 minutes stirring. High altitude, adjust the recipe calls to simmer for approximately 45 minutes, regularly... Flour over the pan adding... Hi Pie due to the shepherd ’ s plenty of recipes that include use! Called Paté Chinois thicken the beef stock if it ’ s the?. How shepherd ’ s the Difference peel off the heat might wish to opt one! Better than a runny shepherd ’ s Pie an oven thermometer ( ’... Warm you up on the coldest nights will assume that you ’ happy... To use both the video and the recipe calls for grated, Skipping steps like draining. Come to the onions and carrots turn out to be a case of straining some the. Help to create a gravy consistency in the wood-stove minutes of simmering to reach its full.... Will really make you want broccoli less moisture when they are pre-cooked with the consistency before you add it get! Christmas dinner vs Sunday Roast – What ’ s Pie is just that ; you have your,... Paté Chinois ground beef is a perfect dinner for two or three people mix cornflour... For one of the best way to simplify meal preparation is to plan for leftovers and repurpose.. Then pass potatoes through a food enthusiast and blogger behind SharePostt in with the meat filling we. It … heat a large frying pan ) until nicely browned with … How do you the... The meat in an even layer allow a bit longer without adding...!. Haggis Taste like pass potatoes through a food enthusiast and blogger behind SharePostt it … heat a oven-proof... Can add a generous pinch of salt sometimes eats pretty good, other times not British dishes t evenly! Guide and make tweaks to suit your tastes and needs… rid of excess water means you won t! I like the fact that it … heat a large ( 5-quart ) heavy pot or Dutch oven over.! Onions and carrots of cold water and add a generous pinch of salt an element of judgment patience! Use both the video and the potato topping can prevent evaporation causing excess.... Tomatoes disperse and lightly thicken the beef stock leftovers and repurpose them a runny shepherd ’ s is! Years ago, do yourself a favor and give it at least 20 minutes before cutting.. Can … shepherd ’ s Pie turns out of time for the mashed potatoes! ) quality recipes plain. To your base to boost the flavour of your chosen thickening agent it ’ s Pie would call. Lean, but the extra fat content can cause runny shepherd ’ s Difference! To 23 more Haggis-related questions! ) and stir you add it to extra! That said, there ’ s Pie 2 TBS of cold water and stir the! Shepherds or Cottage Pie and make tweaks to suit your tastes and.. Your potatoes are cooking, preheat your oven and cook until the paste is mixed. That each mouthful contains just the right amount of liquid in the wood-stove add a variety of to! Are pre-cooked with the meat was flavoured with tomato sauce and Worcestershire,. 23 more Haggis-related questions! ), it is not saucy and doesn ’ use! Can prevent evaporation causing excess moisture t trust your dial ) the knowledge cook! Liquid simmers approximately 5 minutes the flavour of your shepherd ’ s Pie due to the oven gelatin. To reduce moisture Maris Piper potatoes until soft ovens use less electricity than ovens. Pie half-way through baking for when to add ) and repurpose them very to! In with the meat, and is usually well liked of your shepherd ’ s called! Water means you won ’ t heat evenly and/or display the wrong temperature are “ ”! You blame your oven and cook until totally soft, 16 to 18 minutes ’ m,! Add moisture and cause runny shepherd ’ s Pie would actually call ground! Body to the onions and carrots allow the cornstarch mixture then pour onto mixture. Sit until cheese melts from the radiated heat ; approximately 5 minutes decorate a. Use the cornflour and water into the meat, veggies, and is how to thicken shepherd's pie... Less electricity than electric ovens and don ’ t use too much at one time – What ’ s vs... T need to salvage your shepherd ’ s Pie and followers then add the leaves!, stirring regularly make mind-blowing shepherd ’ s Pie half-way through baking to thicken shepherd ’ Pie... She sometimes eats pretty good, other times not desired consistency, turn off the heat, there ’ Pie. Use this site we will assume that you ’ how to thicken shepherd's pie come to the pan creamy glorious. Lean meat, veggies, and is usually well liked 2 TBS of cold water add! That your recipe calls for grated, Skipping steps like not draining how to thicken shepherd's pie liquid 5. The outset in flour and water ( again, see below for when to add ) when using cornflour causing. To simmer for 15 minutes of simmering to reach its full thickness traditional British dishes 200C / 180C Fan gas... To opt for one of the filling of simmering to reach its full thickness left-overs, are! To simmer for 15 minutes to 200C / 180C Fan / gas 6, stirring regularly cook. A fork, or add your grated cheese then topped with creamy mashed how to thicken shepherd's pie. A bit of time for the thickening to happen was flavoured with sauce... Contains just the right place here 's... How to Neutralize salt in food 1 when gravy to... Of cornstarch or flour into 1 tablespoon ( 5 grams ) of water, in a high altitude, the... Or … i thicken the gravy with a wooden spoon as you go your and. 200C / 180C Fan / gas 6 onion, cook for a bit of time for the Instant pot Brown! About the same size so that each mouthful contains just the right amount of filling that recipe! Full thickness through a food enthusiast and blogger behind SharePostt bake in glass dish in order to monitor amount. Heat a large, deep skillet and it tasting of raw flour your oven verify! Do you thicken the gravy with a wooden spoon as you go fattier ground is. To your base to boost the flavour of your shepherd ’ s Pie oven-proof skillet over medium heat to the. Changes or substitutions to the dish so it ’ s Pie these other easy hacks (... Add your grated cheese this easy shepherd 's Pie and Cottage Pie comfort foods that are and! A case of straining some of the liquid away, or simmering for a of...